The Fire Clay tonstein is a kaolinized, airfall volcanic ash bed that was deposited in a widespread late Carboniferous peat-forming mire. Eleven samples from Kentucky and West Virginia, spanning a distance of 200 km, and two samples from Tennessee and Virginia indicate a characteristic mineralogical signature, as compared with other Appalachian tonsteins, consisting of well-crystallized kaolinite, beta-quartz crystal paramorphs, sanidine, ilmenite, zircon, and brookite. Detrital illite and quartz are rarely present or are in very small amounts, which indicates rapid deposition in a mire. Several normal graded cycles in this tonstein suggest repeated episodes of pyroclastic activity that produced a composite ash layer.

A high-silica alkalic rhyolitic source is suggested by the geochemistry of immobile elements and by electron-probe analyses of glass inclusions in volcanic quartz from the Fire Clay tonstein. The rare-earth-element plots (chondrite normalized) of the tonstein show a pronounced negative Eu anomaly and relatively high concentrations of Zr and Th, which are both indicative of a rhyolitic source. Probe analyses of the Fire Clay glass inclusions from four states indicate a chemically identical high-silica rhyolite with peraluminous affinities.

⁴⁰Ar/³⁹Ar sanidine plateau dating indicates an age of 312 ± 1 Ma for the Fire Clay tonstein, which is consistent with previous ⁴⁰Ar/³⁹Ar dates for this tonstein. This age is in agreement with a late Westphalian B age in the European Carboniferous chronostratigraphy on the basis of an age of 311 Ma for the Westphalian B/C boundary.

A new isopachous map of the Fire Clay ash-fall deposit indicates an area of 37,000 km² and a probable source to the present-day southwest. The deposit has a minimum preserved compacted volume of 2.8 km³, which corresponds to an original uncompacted volume of about 20 km³. This preserved volume indicates an ultraplinian volcanic explosion. Pindell and Dewey (1982) proposed an Andean-type arc in this block during the late Carboniferous, prior to South American-North American plate collision. We hypothesize an associated back-arc caldera system in the Yucatan block to explain the high-silica, potassic rhyolitic ash that gave rise to the Fire Clay tonstein.