Understanding tidal marsh trajectories: Evaluation of multiple indicators of marsh persistence

Environmental Research Letters
By: , and 

Links

Abstract

Robust assessments of ecosystem stability are critical for informing conservation and management decisions. Tidal marsh ecosystems provide vital services, yet are globally threatened by anthropogenic alterations to physical and biological processes. A variety of monitoring and modeling approaches have been undertaken to determine which tidal marshes are likely to persist into the future. Here, we conduct the most robust comparison of marsh metrics to date, building on two foundational studies that had previously and independently developed metrics for marsh condition. We characterized pairs of marshes with contrasting trajectories (of marsh cover ) across six regions of the United States, using a combination of remote-sensing and field-based metrics. We also quantified decadal trends in marsh conversion to mudflat/open water at these twelve marshes. Our results suggest that metrics quantifying the distribution of vegetation across an elevational gradient represent the best indicators of marsh trajectories. The unvegetated to vegetated ratio and flood-ebb sediment differential also served as valuable indicators. No single metric universally predicted marsh trajectories, and therefore a more robust approach includes a suite of spatially integrated, landscape-scale metrics that are mostly obtainable from remote sensing. Data from surface elevation tables and marker horizons revealed that degrading marshes can have higher rates of vertical accretion and elevation gain than more intact counterparts, likely due to longer inundation times potentially combined with internal recycling of material. A high rate of elevation gain relative to local sea-level rise has been considered critical to marsh persistence, but our results suggest that it also may serve as a signature of degradation in marshes that have already begun to deteriorate. This investigation, with rigorous comparison and integration of metrics initially developed independently, tested at a broad geographic scale, provides a model for collaborative science to develop management tools for improving conservation outcomes.

Study Area

Additional publication details

Publication type Article
Publication Subtype Journal Article
Title Understanding tidal marsh trajectories: Evaluation of multiple indicators of marsh persistence
Series title Environmental Research Letters
DOI 10.1088/1748-9326/ab5a94
Volume 14
Issue 12
Year Published 2019
Language English
Publisher IOP Science
Contributing office(s) Woods Hole Coastal and Marine Science Center
Description 124073, 13 p.
Country United States
Google Analytic Metrics Metrics page
Additional metadata about this publication, not found in other parts of the page is in this table